A Comparison of Selection at List Time and Time-Stratified Sampling for Estimating Suspended Sediment Loads
نویسنده
چکیده
Time-stratified sampling of sediment for estimating suspended load is introduced and compared to selection at list time (SALT) sampling. Both methods provide unbiased estimates of load and variance. The magnitude of the variance of the two methods is compared using five storm populations of suspended sediment flux derived from turbidity data. Under like conditions, the SALT coefficient of variation was 1.4-7.7 times that of time-stratified sampling. Time-stratified sampling performs well if the range of sediment flux in each stratum is small. This requirement can be met by using small sample sizes in many short strata. Theoretically, SALT sampling has the potential for smaller sampling variance; however, it is difficult to select an auxiliary variable that predicts flux well under diverse flow conditions. An "optimum" auxiliary variable formed from the largest storm performed about as well as time-stratified sampling for the larger storms. Time-stratified sampling ensures that specimens are collected in all storms, facilitating load estimation for individual storms. In contrast, SALT can better allocate sampling resources over different size storms, enabling efficient estimation of the total load for longer periods. Because time-stratified sampling is less sensitive to the way measurements are allocated to different parts of the population, it is preferred for estimating storm loads of multiple constituents from the same sample.
منابع مشابه
An evaluation of flow-stratified sampling for estimating suspended sediment loads
Flow-stratified sampling is a new method for sampling water quality constituents such as suspended sediment to estimate loads. As with selection-at-list-time (SALT) and time-stratified sampling, flow-stratified sampling is a statistical method requiring random sampling, and yielding unbiased estimates of load and variance. It can be used to estimate event yields or to estimate mean concentratio...
متن کاملInvestigation of Temporal Phenomena of Sediment Rating Curve and comparison of it with the Some Statistical Methods for Estimating Suspended Sediment Load (Case study: Gamasiab Watershed)
The variable and complex nature of the sediment load of rivers has led that the estimation of sediment entering the reservoirs and the production of long term sediment, for determining the lifetime of the structures encounter with the problem. Application of sediment rating curves is one of the most common methods for estimating the suspended sediment load of rivers. Regardless of the accuracy ...
متن کاملEstimating Total Suspended Sediment Yield With Probability Sampling
The "Selection At List Time" (SALT) scheme controls sampling of concentration for estimating total suspended sediment yield. The probability of taking a sample is proportional to its estimated contribution to total suspended sediment discharge. This procedure gives unbiased estimates of total suspended sediment yield and the variance of the estimate while automatically emphasizing sampling at h...
متن کاملSystematic Sampling for Suspended Sediment
Because of high costs or complex logistics, scientific populations cannot be measured entirely and must be sampled. Accepted scientific practice holds that sample selection be based on statistical principles to assure objectivity when estimating totals and variances. Probability sampling--obtaining samples with known probabilities--is the only method that assures these results. However, probabi...
متن کاملPiecewise SALT Sampling for Estimating Suspended Sediment Yields
A probability sampling method called SALT (Selection At List 'Time) has been developed for collecting and summarizing data on delivery of suspended sediment in rivers. It is based on sampling and estimating yield using a suspended-sediment rating curve for high discharges and simple random sampling for low flows. The method gives unbiased estimates of total yield and variance. The technique has...
متن کامل